5 Comments

  1. Unknown's avatar

    Hmm, I might be hoping the quotes were properly-used scare-quotes: that is, hoping the freely dispensed substance was some kind of milder fertilizer, and not actual manure.

    A related matter is on my pet-peeves list: people using air-quotes for some printed or written use of quotation marks, when not literally a gestural matter. That is, saying air-quotes in place of the better coinage, the expression scare-quotes.

    True, the confusion has a legit starting place, namely that very often when someone makes that quotation-marks gesture in the air, what they are conveying is the attitude of irony or dubiety, that is, the attitude belonging to scare-quotes. So following on that, someone may associate that attitude so much with the action of making air-quotes that they may look at a written passage and say “Why is this author using air-quotes so much?” when the author surely wasn’t using air-quotes since they weren’t standing next to you, talking and gesturing. They may well have been using (written) scare-quotes.

    Like

  2. Unknown's avatar

    I mean, pretty straightforwards. He’s worried that the source of the “manure” is humans. (And thus it would be more accurately termed “nightsoil.”)

    Like

  3. Unknown's avatar

    “Like” for all three. (The “Like” button was working with Safari for a while, but today it doesn’t.)

    Like

Add a Comment