13 Comments

  1. Unknown's avatar

    I swear I ran into that “salad needs to be tossed” joke elsewhere just the other day! (Maybe it’s becoming an old standard.)
    But I agree with the post’s comment that the customer’s bug-eye reaction here really makes the cartoon work.

  2. Unknown's avatar

    As a kid, I read a lot of bound collections of political cartoons in the library. One of them had Nixon and Ford talking, and Nixon interjected, “Pardon?” at which point Ford started repeating what he’d been saying, but louder.

  3. Unknown's avatar


    Catpivity – a simple reversal of the p and t – would have been simpler, easier to say and more logical than cat-ptivity.

  4. Unknown's avatar

    I cannot see why the customer is any “more” bug-eyed in the third panel than when he showed up initially in the first panel. He’s wearing the same pair of glasses throughout.

    P.S. I agree with Narmitaj that Phoebe’s pun would have worked better with a simple reversal of the dental consonants: “cat-pivity“. The initial “pt” spelling as used in the strip just doesn’t parse well.

  5. Unknown's avatar

    Narmitaj, I had that thought also. But then, the difficulty of the term they actually used could factor in as part of the irritation in the later steps of their interaction.

  6. Unknown's avatar

    And it may not even be tied to the glasses, but more a quirk of the artist’s style. The employee has similar pop eyes, and no glasses.

  7. Unknown's avatar

    @ Deety (1) – Searching for “tossed salad” at GoComics produces dozens of possible examples, but most of the better ones are over ten years old. On the other hand, that “Lucky Cow” strip is old enough to buy alcohol (2003), and the author recycled a similar gag three years later:

  8. Unknown's avatar

    For a salad at Lucky Cow, tossing it is probably the best idea anyway. Let me amend that, for food at Luck Cow . . . .

    As a meta-note, somewhere in my past I seem to recall being taught that if you end a sentence in an ellipsis you should use four dots, to include the period. That would be complicated by the use of the ellipsis Unicode character, but I don’t use that.

Add a Comment