B.A.: Does this question make sense even in Cynthia Logic?
I’d have asked what’s the Nashville of Greece.
Or what’s the Athens of the North in the United States.
(Okay, disclaimer: I have.)
CIDU Bill: I think Nashville adopted the nickname after getting its own Parthenon
Comics I Don't Understand 
Yes, ‘Athens of the North’ or ‘Nashville of Greece’ would each make sense, altho I doubt there’s an answer for either.
LikeLike
I can see where there’d be a lot of towns and small cities calling themselves “Athens of the North,” just as there are many contenders for “the 8th Wonder of the World” (or the 5th Beatle, etc).
LikeLike
Assuming Nashville is in fact the “Athens of the South,” then I would think that Athens would automatically be the “Nashville of Greece.” Both statements mean “Nashville is to the South as Athens is to Greece” (which is equivalent to “Athens is to Greece as Nashville is to the South.”)
LikeLike
I’ve wondered how it was determined that Nashville is Athens’ sister city across the sea. I always took the life size replica of The Parthenon in Centennial Park to be more likely of a response to that designation than a reason.
LikeLike
Shouldn’t Athens, Georgia be the “Athens of the South,” by definition? (And Sparta, New York, is the Sparta of the North.)
LikeLike
And then there’s Manhattan, the Milton Keynes of New York…
LikeLike
Shrug: What do you have against Athens, Alabama?
LikeLike
Apparently, Nashville is the “Athens of the South” because it has so many colleges. It got the name in the 1850s. https://www.tripsavvy.com/athens-of-the-south-2476869
LikeLike
To agree with Shad, the name came before the Parthenon replica.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenon_(Nashville)
LikeLike
Sorry about that, to save you from having to scroll:
“Nashville’s moniker, the “Athens of the South”,[4] influenced the choice of the building as the centerpiece of the 1897 Centennial Exposition.”
LikeLike
BTW, Athens, Georgia is known as the “Manchester of the South” because of all the cotton mills.
LikeLike
And Manchester is known as the “Nashville of the North”, because of all the honky-tonks….
LikeLike
Illinois has “New Athens”. The second word is pronounced with a long ‘A’. Notably the hometown of former Cardinals manager Whitey Herzog.
LikeLike
Boston is the “Athens of America” so Nashville couldn’t be that. “The Athens of Tennessee” wouldn’t do because every state could have its Athens. So it had to be the Athens of the South. But if, say, St. Paul were the “Boston of the Midwest” then it would be the “Athens of America of the Midwest.”
LikeLike
Actually, its Springfields all the way down. (And occasional turtles.)
LikeLike
Thanks, Shad and WW: I asked a few people when I was there, couldn’t get a straight answer, then forgot about the question until today.
LikeLike
As a native Nashvillian, I’ve always been told it’s because we’re a center of the arts and culture. (“The arts” mostly referring to country music.) At least that’s what we tell each other.
Yeah, things have gone a bit downhill since the 1850s.
LikeLike
But so many cities and towns upstate NY are named after Greek cities.
Bill, the Parthenon looked a lot different in the movie “Nashville” when the huge concert and end of the movie is set there. – But heck, “It don’t worry me” (the final song at the end of the movie,sung at the Parthenon).
LikeLike
When I took Spanish in high school (a not very successful project) we were told that the Barcelona is the Pittsburgh of Spain. (Presumably due to steel production.) My reaction ever since is to refer to Pittsburgh as the Barcelona of the US.
LikeLike
Well, it was many years between my seeing Nashville and my visiting Nashville.
LikeLike
I’m surprised any European city would go along with being identified as the [American city] of [whatever their country is].
LikeLike
New Orleans has been new for quite a while; I’d have expected a New New Orleans by now, or at least a Newer Orleans.
LikeLike